X is for eXtremely Loud and Incredibly Close (2011)

Blogging from A-Z

Extremely loud and incredibly close film poster.jpgThis movie was so emotional and it broke my heart more than once.  Oskar Schell, a boy who has problems dealing with other people, loses his father in the attacks of 9/11.  Through a series of flashbacks we see the close relationship he had with his father and how his father worked hard to get Oskar to overcome his discomfort with strangers by planning a series of scavenger hunts around New York City.  After 9/11 his relationship with his mother deteriorates but he does become closer to his grandmother who lives across the street.  On the one year anniversary , Oskar finds a key and the name Black marked on an envelope in his Dad’s untouched closet.  So begins his quest to find the Black that can help him find what the key opens.

When I saw all of the reviews for this book and movie I thought that it would be too emotionally heart wrenching for me and I was right.  I knew Jason would like it, so we watched it over a few nights and we were blown away by the story and the actor who played Oskar.  Tom Hanks and Sandra Bullock were great in their roles, but Oskar was the movie.  This was Thomas Horn’s first acting role and I am surprised that he wasn’t nominated for an Oscar.

The critic’s didn’t like this one very much although it did get nomitated for a Best Picture Oscar.  It makes an obvious attempt to play on your emotions, at times I found it hard to watch Oskar, but I think it is successful. Some movies that try to manipulate your emotions aren’t as smart or have the edge this one has.  It is a drama wrapped in tears and achievement.  When Oskar finally finds the Black who could help him I was devastated for him.

Since this is Autism Awareness Month I should note that Jason and I both thought Oskar had Asperger’s, a condition on the autism spectrum, so I did a little digging after the movie.  The author of the book, Jonathan Safran Foer, says that he did not think of Oskar that way when writing the book.  The director of the film, Stephen Daldry, says Oskar is “a special child who is somewhere on the autistic spectrum, trying to find his own logic – trying to make sense of something that literally doesn’t make sense to him.”  So I do wonder what those of you who read the book and saw the movie thought. Did you think Oskar was portrayed differently in both?  I am sure now that I’ve seen the movie that I am not going to read the book and I want to know what you think.

9 thoughts on “X is for eXtremely Loud and Incredibly Close (2011)

  1. boardinginmyforties says:

    I really want to read the book first and then watch the movie. I know this one will be gut wrenching for me too!

  2. Lloyd Russell says:

    Didn’t see the movie so am probably not the best person to make a comment. However, I did read the book. It was a tough book to read. It didn’t grab me emotionally, as so many books do, because of the style in which the book was written. It’s hard to explain, but there are too many odd sentence constructions. I understand that it’s written in the voice of the son, but it just made it that much harder to read – at least for me.

  3. sandynawrot says:

    I read the book but didn’t see the movie. I struggled with it. I loved Oskar (and yes I do believe he was on the autism spectrum and I don’t know how on earth the author didn’t intend for that to be!) but I REALLY didn’t like the chapters about the grandparents. They were very very strange and for me it offset all the charm that Oskar brought to the novel.

  4. hmsgofita says:

    I loved the book and enjoyed the movie. Book was better, in my opinion. I thought visually with the book, the author did some pretty amazing things. I’d at least think about reading it! But I do feel that he came off as on the autism spectrum but maybe he didn’t intend to do that because he was trying to portray a really smart boy dealing with his father’s death….but it was easier to have that goal in mind for the movie.

    But both are fabulous!

  5. Literary Feline says:

    I haven’t yet seen the movie (or read the book), but I do hope to at some point. It sounds like quite a powerful story.

  6. Jenners says:

    I read the book but haven’t seen the movie yet so I can’t decide if Oskar was different. The book broke my heart too (it includes photos at the end that had me sobbing). I really do need to see the movie now I realize.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s