The problem with lists

I love lists.  When I started this blog over 4 years ago, I thought it would be fun to come up with a Top 100 list so I did.

My Top 100 movie list is more accurate than my book list because I rewatch favorite movies all the time.  The initial list took some time, but I feel pretty good about it.  Every month or so I try to review a favorite movie and before I do I watch it again and adjust how high on the list it should be.  In the 3 or so years I’ve been doing this, two movies after another viewing, didn’t make the cut.  This week I asked Jason if he wanted to watch #21 with me and he said yes, so over two nights we watched it.  And spent most of the time making fun of it.  I couldn’t believe it.  It just did not age well.  Alien was filmed in 1979 and it shows.  My memories did not match the movie at all.  I was so disappointed and will have to take it off my list.

So, has this happened to you?  Do you remember loving a book or a movie or a song and then when you read/watch. hear it again it’s terrible?

27 thoughts on “The problem with lists

  1. Scott Nagele says:

    Not so much with moives. More so with the list of girls I had a crush on in high school. When I come across one of them now, I think, “Wow, she’s like 45! Why would a 16 year-old want to have a crush on a 45-year-old?”

  2. BermudaOnion says:

    Your top 100 book list is what first attracted me to your blog! Some movies don’t age well – we watched a Star Wars movie recently and we didn’t think it had aged well.

    • stacybuckeye says:

      I think with the old sci-fi it’s just so hard after watching the current movies. I couldn’t believe how dated it was. And I remembered the storyline being more compelling. At least Stars Wars had that!
      Always good to know what people look at and enjoy on my blog 🙂

  3. Adam says:

    I think it’s an ambitious enough project to even go for a personal top 100 list. I’d probably stop at a top 10 or 20 for that kind of list.

    I re-read the Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy books last summer, and while I still really enjoyed the first book, some of the later ones didn’t hold up as well as I remembered them.

    • stacybuckeye says:

      As with Alien and Star Wars I wonder if sci-fi, more than some of the other genres, is less timeless because of the great leaps in science. Something to consider, I guess.

  4. Tea Time with Marce says:

    I can’t think of any but many I loved as a child, I wonder if I will love as much with my own child. eg, ET, Pippi Longstocking, Annie, Gigi etc. An all time movie for me is Silence of the Lambs, as amazing now as it was then.

    Would love to see your movie list.

  5. Margot says:

    I don’t think I’ve ever told you this but I’ve checked your list from time to time the last few years. It’s a very good resource when I’m looking for a movie to watch. I like that Philadelphia Story is still at the top.

  6. Becky Griffiths says:

    Hi Stacy–I thought Psycho was kind of corn-ball when I went back and saw it again–hard to believe that it once seemed so scary. I noticed that you had To Kill a Mockingbird as your second favorite book, but it’s not on your favorite movie list–it’s actually my favorite book AND movie, which is funny because when someone really loves a book, they are usually disappointed in the movie.

  7. Mary says:

    Funny, I was just thinking the same about some of the books I read years ago. I wondered if I’d rate them higher or lower now than I did then (I was comparing books with another Goodreads reader’s list of similar books read). With movies, in some cases (sci-fi to be sure) it can be painful because the technical advancements can render a movie almost silly after a decade or two. With books, the reader changes in maturity, tastes, etc. Good question.

  8. thebumbles says:

    West Side Story. Loved it when I was a kid. Watched it again while in college with a large group of gals and guys. We all just sat there trying not to laugh. How can you take a gang banger seriously when he’s doing ballet leaps and snapping all the time? Songs were still good – but my initial love-fest with the film crashed and burned. Bummer. Some things we just shouldn’t re-visit and let them stay cool in our memories.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s